a moment of differences
Some Sundays, the readings are a delight to explore, research, and wonder about. On others, the puzzle seems too hard, especially when the Gospel includes a parable, like today. The parable of the shrewd manager left me perplexed the first few times I read it, and there is little commentary in the many bible versions I use to research. So I will circle back to it in a bit, but for now, let’s enjoy the simplicity of Paul’s message to Timothy.
“First of all I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions and thanksgivings be made for everyone, for kings and all who are in high positions so that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and dignity.”
Take a deep breath because today’s readings are far from quiet and peaceable. In fact, Jeremiah’s experience is anguish over the exile and suffering of his people: “My joy is gone, grief is upon me, my heart is sick.” His words resonated deeply with me as I read them again and again this week. With all the unrest and suffering in the world around us, my heart aches, and I am longing for a quiet and peaceable life. I want to close my doors and shut out the world and all its turmoil. And yet my awareness of this turmoil and my relationship with God means I cannot.
I could easily relate to Jeremiah, who was separated from his people and yet identified with their pain. He knows they have provoked God’s anger, and yet he weeps for them. Jeremiah lived with a deep awareness of God’s love and grieved for those who did not, regardless of their actions.
Jeremiah’s grief is a prophetic activity; his tears are the prelude to an openness to new possibilities.
A quiet, peaceable life is not the experience of our psalmist either, as angry complaints pour out
“Look at what they have done.
Pour out your wrath upon the heathen!
But, God remember not our past sins;
let your compassion be swift to meet us.”
The psalmist has a different outlook than Jeremiah. Heathens are heathens, the faithful are the faithful, and the differences between them are outlined clearly. Those who know God deserve God’s mercy, and those who do not know him deserve his wrath.
How did we come to this in a world where a loving God created everyone?
In our children’s Godly Play program this week, we told the second story of creation found in chapter 2 of Genesis. I wasn’t supposed to be the storyteller. Still, in my absent-minded calendar-keeping, a serendipitous moment occurred because the beauty of this creation story made today’s scriptures clearer to me.
God created everything in love, and it was good.
He placed the first person in the garden, who was Adam, which means “everyone.” Eve was with Adam and part of Adam; they were together like one person, Adam-Eve. Adam-Eve was together with the garden and with God.
There were two mysterious trees in the garden. One was the tree of knowledge. If you ate the fruit from this tree, you would begin to notice differences like the difference between good and evil and up and down. The other was the tree of life. If you ate the fruit from the tree of life, you would live forever.
God told Adam-Eve not to eat from the tree of knowledge.
Of all the creatures in the garden, the serpent was the cleverest. The serpent convinced Adam-Eve to eat from the tree of knowledge and they did.
And everything fell apart. Adam-Eve became Adam and Eve.
And they began to notice the differences like the differences between close and far, Adam and Eve, high and low, people and God, good and evil, near and far.
God looked for them, and they hid.
They no longer knew how to be close to God or each other as they had been before.
They longed to return to the way things were, but they could not; they could only move forward. God placed a flaming sword and a fierce angel at the edge of the garden so they could not go back and eat from the tree of forever.
They came from dust and would return to dust. But God gave them a gift when things fell apart. They could now take the differences they saw and put them together in new ways. They could not make something from nothing like God, but they could sometimes make something good from what they now knew and what they remembered from the love in God’s garden. God was with them always, and he is always with us.
It is not likely that it was Adam-Eve’s intention to separate from each other and cause creation to fall apart when they chose this course of action.
But here we are in a world clearly full of differences, wondering how to move forward and how to create something new from what we see.
Can we return to a quiet, peaceful life that includes everyone?
As I revisit our parable in Luke. I return to trying to puzzle it out.
What is it trying to tell us? Is it good to be shrewd?
When the manager was let go from his position due to his behavior, he chose, in self-preservation, to cut a deal.
Mosaic law prohibits collecting interest from fellow Jews. It is speculated that the manager had originally been overcharging as a means of circumventing this law. And commentators suggest that to win the favor of those indebted to the master, he simply removed the interest.
This clever move ingratiated him with those in debt and also with his master, as he created a reputation of generosity for the master.
The shrewd manager took a financial mess and made something new.
Inadvertently, he made things better for everyone. Now, we cannot really commend him on this because it appears to be purely motivated by selfishness. But we cannot really make him the villain either.
The manager may have helped others for entirely selfish reasons, but he helped them nonetheless.
We cannot villainize the serpent for being in the garden, because God created the garden and everything in it, including the clever serpent.
We cannot decide that Adam and Eve are villains either, even though they made a decision that caused division and all of creation to fall apart.
We cannot villainize the master or the manager because of their role in life, any more than we can villainize Jesus’ friend Judas.
Judas, like Adam and Eve, teaches us about differences. The difference between leaning into love and pulling away from it.
We often think of the good as being first because in our story of the garden, it is.
But we don’t live in the garden, and what if shrewdness, self-serving, and survival came first and was all that was known to us until now?
What if this is the first time we can see the differences from the other side, and now we can choose something new?
The life we are born into and the life we live both affect our ability to see the beauty of holiness and feel the touch of love.
Our psalmist doesn’t sound like he is feeling the loving touch of God. He wants justice. He is pleading with God while still holding onto the differences. He is not ready for the healing that can come from creating something new.
Jeremiah, with his heart broken wide open, holds truth, without blame, grieves a societal disaster, and pleads for healing.
He would weep all day long, a fountain of tears, for those who have fallen apart.
I am still quite puzzled by the parable told today. The message will take some more sorting out for me. But that is the nature and beauty of the parable of Jesus.
And, I don’t need to understand it all at once.
I believe that though we may not be able to return to the quiet, peaceable life of innocence, we can move forward in godliness and dignity as we remember to pray.
Like Jeremiah, we can remember that God does not abandon us because of our mistakes, and we can choose not to abandon others because of theirs. We can let our hearts be torn open for all who are suffering and pray.
We can learn from the psalmist to give our anger over to God, and let go of our desire to hold onto differences and pray.
Pray for our leaders both in our country and the world.
Pray for our neighbors and friends who are exiled from their homes and separated from a quiet and peaceable life.
And when opportunity arises to ease the burden of others, we can be both shrewd and a child of the light.
May we find within us a quiet and peaceable life as we seek to bring peace to others in the midst of our differences.
And may we remember…
There is one God;
There is also one mediator between God and humankind,
Christ Jesus, himself human,
who gave himself a ransom for all.
Amen.
